The Temporary Dissonance

Peeling potatoes for dinner, I was listening to music — a lovely arrangement around a poem by Robert Frost.  Of course, I couldn’t help but sing along until . . .


The clock in the living room began chiming the hour.

The sudden dissonance stopped my singing, but not my enjoyment, because I love that clock, and because I knew that the dissonance that its chime created was only temporary.

Sure enough, the chiming stopped and the song continued, but I wasn’t singing anymore.  The interruption had sent my thoughts onto the track of another dissonance that was slowing my preparation for Sunday’s class.  It’s always a gift to be surprised by a text.  (We “tame” the Word of God to our peril.)  The Hebrews 5 examination of Jesus’ role as our high priest brings on a collision of concepts in verse eight:

” . . . though He was a Son, yet He learned obedience by the things which He suffered.”

Christ’s “Son-ship” (His deity) qualified Him to represent us before God, and to be the perfect priest and sacrifice for sin,  and yet the verse focuses on His learning obedience.  He was present at creation, and yet He became a learner.  Here’s where I had to take a step back and let myself enjoy the dissonance.  Obviously, as God, He needed to learn nothing, but in taking on human flesh, He had to experience everything we experience, or, as Warren Wiersbe puts it, He experienced “the sinless infirmities” of human nature.

It is also true that, as God the Son, Jesus had never experienced suffering.  Clothed in humanity, however, he was subject not only to piercing and death, but also to the daily viscissitudes and exigencies that plague us and that comprise most of what the average person experiences as “suffering” on this planet.

Hebrews 5:7 pulls back the curtain on the truth of Jesus’ wrestling with God:

“He . . . offered up prayers and supplications, with vehement cries and tears to Him who was able to save Him from death . . .”,

“Jesus Christ, the Righteous,” in Whom there was no sin, experienced terror over the prospect of becoming the sin-bearer, and I find myself, again, pondering this dissonance.  Was His temptation in the wilderness an actual test?  Could Jesus have made shipwreck the plan of God?  Can there be a valid wrestling in the heart of a Son who is one with the Father?

With every aspect of the incarnation, reason argues for a 50/50 split.  We want a theology that we can get our heads around; however, orthodoxy argues for the truth of “fully God, fully man.”  Theologian Addison Leitch spoke of driving a stake in the ground representing one doctrine (Jesus’ humanity, for example) and then driving another stake in the ground representing a seemingly conflicting doctrine (His deity).  No amount of reasoning can ever bring those stakes together.

So, peeling potatoes, listening to music, and enjoying the friendly sound of a chiming clock in the background, I also hold these two conflicting concepts in my mind — with joy!  They help to reinforce for me the absolute other-ness of God.

This is NOT an argument for flabby thinking or lazy, “I-dunno” theology.  Through the writer of Hebrews, God is calling us to a rigorous consideration of truth — a feat which is impossible without opening ourselves to the reality of dissonance.

Like the chime of the clock in my home, I know this dissonance to be temporary, for it will pass one day when I no longer see through a glass darkly.  In the meantime, I will neither silence the clock nor turn down the music, but I will love both truths, knowing that when the clock has ceased its chiming forever and all dissonance has passed away, we will see Him face to face, and all will be made plain.


Photo credit:  Jon Ottosson

Thanks for joining us in our study of The Epistle to the Hebrews, a letter to a congregation of struggling Jewish Christians written by an unknown author sometime before the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 A.D.  My Sunday school class and I will be landing on a few verses in each chapter with the goal of getting an overview of this fascinating and complex book.  These mid-week reflections and observations are intended to initiate a deeper pondering of the week’s assignment in preparation for our discussion the following Sunday.  It’s not too late to catch up by reading Hebrews 1 -5, and, if you’re interested, last week’s blog post.

Subscribe to get regular Bible studies and book reviews from Living Our Days delivered to your inbox.  Just enter your e-mail address in the box at the top of this page.

I link-up with these communities on a regular basis:   Soli Deo Gloria Connections, Inspire Me Mondays, Good Morning Mondays, Soul Survival, Testimony Tuesday, Titus 2 Tuesday, Tell His Story, Coffee for Your Heart, Live Free Thursdays, Faith-Filled Fridays, Grace and TruthStill Saturday, Weekend Whispers, Sunday Stillness, Faith and Fellowship, Blessing Counters, Women with Intention, Sharing His Beauty, Monday Musings, Motivate and Rejuvenate Monday, Thought Provoking Thursday, Small Wonder, Playdates with God,  A Little R & R, Beloved Brews, SusanBMead, Faith Along the Way, Cozy Reading Spot, Reflect, Literacy Musing Mondays, Purposeful Faith, The Loft, Words with Winter, Rich Faith Rising, Encourage Me Monday, Tuesday Talk, What to Read Wednesday, Booknificent Thursday, Give Me Grace, Three-Word Wednesday, Word-filled Wednesdays, Faith ‘n Friends, Essential Things, 100 Happy Days, His Purpose in Me, After My Coffee, Thankful Thursday



Published by

Michele Morin

Michele Morin is a teacher, blogger, reader, and gardener who finds joy in sitting at a table surrounded by women with open Bibles. She has been married to an unreasonably patient husband for nearly 30 years, and together they have four sons, two daughters-in-love, two grandchildren, and one lazy St. Bernard. Michele loves hot tea and well-crafted sentences, poems that stop her in her tracks and days at the ocean with the whole family. She laments biblical illiteracy and advocates for the prudent use of “little minutes.” She blogs at Living Our Days, and you can connect with her on Facebook or Twitter.

22 thoughts on “The Temporary Dissonance”

  1. Michelle, I love this post. I am a thinker and I think God calls us to be. I don’t think the truth of Jesus being both God and man is an easy concept. We are human and in our flesh can only attempt at understanding. Yet, I do know that Jesus left His preternatural gifts in heaven and one of those was the ‘intellect driving the will”, part of the curse was that we live under the opposite, the will drives the intellect until we by ‘learn obedience by the things we suffer’ . In order for Jesus to be fully human, He had to suffer for obedience just like we do and because He is God, He could set those preternatural gifts aside. Just a thought. Blessings, from your neighbor at Three Word Wednesday.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Much to ponder here about the “absolute otherness” of God, Michele. These truths aren’t either/or; they’re both/and–whether I can comprehend them or not! I love it when such richness flows from something as simple as being interrupted by a chiming clock!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Are you teaching this class, Michele? Oh how I wish I could attend! Funny how our minds can travel a million miles, galaxies away, to contemplate theological while peeling potatoes. I’ve always wondered at that “He learned obedience” verse myself!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Wouldn’t it be fun to get all our blogging friends together? Yes, I’m teaching Hebrews in the women’s class at my church. The blog posts are my gentle mid-week “nag” — “Are you doing your homework?” and just a way to keep us thinking about the chapter throughout the week.


  4. Michele- One of my favorite posts right here. I love Hebrews and dissonance- the working title of a book I’ve been writing was Dissonance for the longest time. You capture it’s essence so well. Praise the Lord for the dissonance that makes us more alert, more aware of His otherness, and more in awe!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Thanks for acknowledging the TENSION in our understanding of God. We are stretched thin on two truths (like justice and mercy) and it is useless to pretend that we can hug the one or the other and let the other go!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Always soothed by the driving of those two pegs -humanity / deity. He is both and. For me this is enough and helps me resolve the otherness of my own life as spirit and flesh. I love this offering. You’re the #GiveMeGrace Wordsmith of the Week.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. Very interesting. I learned about dissonance in my watercolour painting. If you want something to stand out – something usual – larger, darker, different colour.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.